People have been trying to test extrasensory perception under controlled conditions for about a century. The methods have grown more careful and the arguments more detailed, but the central question remains unsettled. This guide describes the main chapters, with people, decades and links to further reading, and argues for no conclusion, because the field has reached none.
Duke University in the 1930s
Joseph Banks Rhine trained as a botanist and moved to Duke University in North Carolina in 1927 to work with the psychologist William McDougall. There, with his wife Louisa, he began systematic card-guessing experiments using the five-symbol deck his colleague Karl Zener had designed (see the Zener cards guide). Rhine coined the term extrasensory perception, or ESP, and his 1934 monograph of that title reported tens of thousands of trials, many above the one-in-five chance level.
The best-known series was run with a divinity student, Hubert Pearce, in 1933 and 1934, with Rhine's assistant J. G. Pratt handling the cards in a separate building. Across 1,850 trials Pearce was reported to score 558 hits against 370 expected. Duke established a Parapsychology Laboratory under Rhine in 1935.
Criticism came quickly: loose shuffling, cards readable from the back, recording errors and selective reporting. Rhine tightened his procedures in response. Other laboratories in the late 1930s mostly failed to reproduce the strong early results, and in the 1960s the psychologist C. E. M. Hansel argued that Pearce could have left his building and watched the cards. Rhine retired from Duke in 1965 and his work continued at the Foundation for Research on the Nature of Man, which he had set up in 1962; in 1995 it was renamed the Rhine Research Center and still operates in Durham. See Zener cards and J. B. Rhine on Wikipedia.
The ganzfeld era
By the 1970s the field had moved from card guessing towards free-response designs. Charles Honorton, who had worked on dream telepathy studies at the Maimonides Medical Center in New York, began using the ganzfeld procedure in 1974. A receiver sits in mild sensory isolation, halved ping-pong balls over the eyes, red light, white noise, and describes whatever comes to mind while a sender in another room looks at a randomly chosen picture. The receiver is then shown four candidates and picks the best match. Chance is 1 in 4.
In 1985 the psychologist Ray Hyman published a critique of the ganzfeld database, citing flaws in randomisation and security; Honorton replied, and in 1986 the two set out joint standards a convincing study would need to meet. Honorton's laboratory ran an automated version, the autoganzfeld, from 1983 to 1989; the results, published with Daryl Bem in Psychological Bulletin in 1994, reported a hit rate of about 32 percent against a chance rate of 25. A 1999 analysis by Julie Milton and Richard Wiseman of later studies found no significant effect overall; a 2010 analysis by Lance Storm and colleagues, using different inclusion rules, found a small positive one. Which studies belong in the count has never been settled. See Ganzfeld experiment on Wikipedia.
SRI, remote viewing and the Stargate Project
In 1972 the physicists Harold Puthoff and Russell Targ began a programme at the Stanford Research Institute in California to study what they called remote viewing: a person tries to describe a distant location or hidden object, and independent judges later rate the description against the real target and decoys. Targ and Puthoff published in Nature in 1974, and the work drew funding first from the CIA and later from the Defense Intelligence Agency.
The government programme ran for more than two decades under a series of code names and from 1991 was known as Star Gate, by then managed by Edwin May at SAIC. In 1995 the CIA commissioned a review from the American Institutes for Research, whose two external reviewers split: the statistician Jessica Utts concluded that the effect was statistically real; Ray Hyman concluded that the evidence did not justify that claim. The programme was closed that year and its files declassified. Critics, notably David Marks and Richard Kammann in 1978, argued that the SRI judging had been compromised by cues in the transcripts; defenders pointed to later, better-controlled series. See Russell Targ and Stargate Project on Wikipedia.
The replication debate
In 2011 Daryl Bem published nine experiments in the Journal of Personality and Social Psychology under the title Feeling the Future, reporting that participants' responses were influenced by events that had not yet happened. Attempts to repeat the key experiments, including a 2012 effort by Stuart Ritchie, Richard Wiseman and Christopher French, found nothing. The episode became one of the triggers for psychology's wider reckoning with replication and for preregistering a study's design before the data are collected.
The mainstream position can be stated plainly. ESP has not been accepted as established. Reported effects are small, inconsistent across laboratories and lack a mechanism compatible with current physics. Proponents reply that the combined evidence across decades is statistically stronger than for many accepted findings. Both sides agree on one thing: progress means counting hits against a known chance level, honestly, in advance, many times over.
Where Sixth sits
Sixth borrows the instrument and the arithmetic, not the conclusions. The Symbols mode is a Zener-style five-option guess; the Sense Score is a Z-score, the statistic Rhine's critics and defenders argued over. The app's description says it was inspired by classic Zener card experiments and modern parapsychology research; its terms say the results are for entertainment and self-exploration, not scientific advice. It offers a private version of the question those researchers asked: over many guesses, do your hits sit where chance puts them? The measurement guide explains how to read the answer.
Common questions
Did Rhine prove that ESP exists?
No, in the sense that his results were not accepted by the wider scientific community then or since. His early series produced numbers far above chance, but critics identified ways information could have leaked, and other laboratories did not reliably reproduce the effects. He did establish the method: fixed odds, counted hits, statistics agreed in advance.
Was the Stargate Project a success?
Its own reviewers disagreed. Utts found statistically significant effects in the laboratory data; Hyman did not find the evidence persuasive. The 1995 review concluded that remote viewing had not produced information useful for intelligence operations, and the programme ended.
Is the ganzfeld effect real?
It depends on which studies are counted and who is counting. Meta-analyses in 1994 and 2010 reported an effect; one in 1999 did not. It remains the most studied design in the field, and the most contested.